RFC: Should a bookmarked ticket disappear when it is deleted?

RT Users
1

Hi all,

at the moment, deletion trumps bookmarks in RT 3.8. I can see how this
can make sense. I can also see how bookmarks trumping deletion would
make sense.

Personally, I would tend to have bookmarks trump deletion, because a
bookmark is the deliberate decision of a single user that he/she wants
to keep track of this issue whereas a deletion means that someone
decided the issue is not interesting for anyone.
Specific over generic and all that… :stuck_out_tongue:

Thoughts, verbal abuse, beer vouchers?
Richard

2

Hi all,

at the moment, deletion trumps bookmarks in RT 3.8. I can see how this
can make sense. I can also see how bookmarks trumping deletion would
make sense.

Personally, I would tend to have bookmarks trump deletion, because a
bookmark is the deliberate decision of a single user that he/she wants
to keep track of this issue whereas a deletion means that someone
decided the issue is not interesting for anyone.
Specific over generic and all that… :stuck_out_tongue:

Delete should mean “disappears from all listings”

Bookmarking should trump resolve or reject, though

3

Delete should mean “disappears from all listings”

Bookmarking should trump resolve or reject, though

Should I file a wishlist item or will you keep track of it yourself?

Richard